Image MIME Reference
APNG
Animated Portable Network Graphics
image/vnd.mozilla.apng
VS
CMU Window Manager Raster
image/x-cmu-raster
CMU-Raster
A complete technical comparison of Animated Portable Network Graphics and CMU Window Manager Raster — covering compression, feature support, browser compatibility, magic bytes, and when to choose each format.
APNG wins on browser support
Feature Support
| Feature | APNG | CMU-Raster |
|---|---|---|
| Transparency (Alpha) | Yes | ✕ No |
| Animation Support | Yes | ✕ No |
| Progressive Loading | Yes | ✕ No |
| HDR Support | ✕ No | ✕ No |
| EXIF Metadata | Yes | ✕ No |
| ICC Color Profile | Yes | ✕ No |
Animated Portable Network Graphics
image/vnd.mozilla.apng
Extension
.apng.png
Container
PNG Chunk Stream
Compression
Deflate (Lossless)
Algorithm
Deflate (zlib)
Color Depth
8-bit (Indexed), 24-bit (TrueColor), 32-bit (RGBA)
Developed by
Mozilla Corporation (Stuart Parmenter & Vladimir Vukićević)
Released
2004
Magic Bytes
89 50 4E 47 0D 0A 1A 0A
CMU Window Manager Raster
image/x-cmu-raster
Extension
.ras
Container
CMU Window Manager Bitmap
Compression
Uncompressed
Algorithm
None
Color Depth
1-bit (Monochrome), 8-bit (Indexed/Grayscale)
Developed by
Carnegie Mellon University (CMU)
Released
1980s
Magic Bytes
F1 00 40 BB
Browser Support Comparison
| Browser | APNG | CMU-Raster |
|---|---|---|
Chrome
|
✓ 59
|
✕ |
Firefox
|
✓ 3
|
✕ |
Safari
|
✓ 8
|
✕ |
Edge
|
✓ 79
|
✕ |
IE (Legacy)
|
✕ | ✕ |
APNG
APNG Strengths
- Supports 8-bit alpha transparency, completely solving the ugly 'white halo' problem inherent to GIFs
- Gracefully degrades; viewers that do not support APNG will render a perfectly valid, static PNG of the first frame
- Provides lossless compression that retains absolute pixel-perfect quality for UI elements and line art
Limitations
- Because it relies on lossless Deflate compression, file sizes for complex, video-like animations can be massive compared to lossy formats like WebP or AVIF
- Was initially rejected by the official PNG group, delaying its adoption for nearly a decade
- Lacks native hardware decoding acceleration, unlike video-based animated formats (like MP4 or WebM)
CMU-Raster
CMU-Raster Strengths
- Incredibly simple, uncompressed binary structure that was easy for early, memory-constrained UNIX workstations to parse and render
Limitations
- Completely obsolete and unsupported outside of niche historical command-line tools like Netpbm
- The shared '.ras' file extension causes frequent file misidentification and system conflicts
- Lacks all modern imaging features, including metadata, compression, and alpha channel transparency
When to choose which format
APNG
Use APNG when…
- High-Quality Web Animations
- Stickers (Apple iMessage, LINE, Discord)
- UI Loaders with Alpha Transparency
- GIF Replacement
CMU-Raster
Use CMU-Raster when…
- Historical UNIX / Andrew Project Archival
- Legacy Academic Computing Research