Free webp to jpg
EN
Image MIME Reference
Apple-ICNS

Apple Icon Image

image/x-icns
VS

JPEG XL

image/jxl
JXL

A complete technical comparison of Apple Icon Image and JPEG XL — covering compression, feature support, browser compatibility, magic bytes, and when to choose each format.

JXL wins on browser support

Feature Support

Feature Apple-ICNS JXL
Transparency (Alpha) Yes Yes
Animation Support ✕ No Yes
Progressive Loading ✕ No Yes
HDR Support ✕ No Yes
EXIF Metadata ✕ No Yes
ICC Color Profile Yes Yes
Apple Icon Image
image/x-icns
Extension
.icns
Container Chunk-based (OSType Header)
Compression Uncompressed (Legacy) / PNG (Modern) / JPEG 2000 (Modern)
Algorithm
NoneDeflate (via embedded PNG)Wavelet (via embedded JP2)
Color Depth 1-bit (Monochrome), 4-bit, 8-bit, 24-bit (RGB), 32-bit (RGBA)
Developed by Apple Inc.
Released 2001
Magic Bytes
69 63 6E 73
Full Apple-ICNS reference →
JPEG XL
image/jxl
Extension
.jxl
Container ISOBMFF / JPEG XL Codestream
Compression Lossy (VarDCT) / Lossless (Modular)
Algorithm
VarDCT (Variable block-size DCT)Modular (Predictive coding for lossless)
Color Depth 8-bit, 10-bit, 12-bit, 16-bit, 32-bit (Float)
Developed by Joint Photographic Experts Group (JPEG)
Released 2021
Magic Bytes
FF 0A (Codestream) / 00 00 00 0C 4A 58 4C 20 0D 0A 87 0A (Container)
Full JXL reference →

Browser Support Comparison

Browser Apple-ICNS JXL
Chrome Chrome
✕ ✕
Firefox Firefox
✕ ✕
Safari Safari
✕
✓ 17+
Edge Edge
✕ ✕
IE IE (Legacy)
✕ ✕
Apple-ICNS

Apple-ICNS Strengths

  • Seamlessly handles multi-resolution scaling on macOS, perfectly serving both standard and high-DPI (Retina) displays from a single asset
  • Modern versions efficiently embed standard PNG files, making it much easier to parse the high-resolution layers than the legacy raw pixel formats
Limitations
  • Strictly bound to the Apple ecosystem; completely useless natively on Windows, Linux, or the Web
  • The internal chunking structure is notoriously messy, utilizing dozens of different undocumented, legacy OSType tags spanning 20+ years of Apple history
JXL

JXL Strengths

  • Capable of losslessly recompressing legacy JPEG files, saving ~20% space while retaining perfect byte-for-byte restorability
  • Highly superior progressive decoding (Saliency-driven), allowing recognizable images to load extremely fast on slow connections
  • Outperforms WebP and competes favorably with AVIF, especially at high-fidelity settings and for complex textures/photography
  • Royalty-free with an open-source reference implementation (libjxl)
Limitations
  • Google's removal of JXL support from Chrome severely hindered its adoption as a universal web standard
  • Lack of hardware decoding chips compared to video-derived codecs like AVIF (AV1)
  • File parsing logic is complex due to the split between raw codestreams and ISOBMFF containers

When to choose which format

Apple-ICNS
Use Apple-ICNS when…
  • macOS Application Bundles (.app)
  • macOS Folder Customization
  • Apple Disk Image (.dmg) Styling
JXL
Use JXL when…
  • High-End Web Delivery (via Safari/Polyfills)
  • HDR Photography
  • Legacy JPEG Archiving
  • Digital Art & Image Storage

More comparisons

Apple-ICNS vs ACES → JXL vs ACES → Apple-ICNS vs APNG → JXL vs APNG → Apple-ICNS vs AVCI → JXL vs AVCI → Apple-ICNS vs AVCS → JXL vs AVCS → Apple-ICNS vs AVIF → JXL vs AVIF → All comparisons →
Share this comparison